Carmichael Outreach Reflection

Last week, for my Health Education class, we broke into two groups and toured Carmichael Outreach, a community based organization in Regina that “serves the marginalized of Regina by advocating on their behalf and by providing a range of programming that includes preventative measures and harm reduction.”  They emphasize a non-judgmental environment and a person to person approach, rather than a medical approach.

Carmichael Outreach offers a huge variety of programs, including a coffee room, community garden, food security and nutrition, a housing coordinator, an immunization program, a needle exchange program, used clothing and small household item depot, and more.  I had no idea that all of these programs were available in Regina, let alone all these programs being offered from one organization.

As I walked into the doors of Carmichael, soup cans in hand, I immediately felt very out of place.  First impression:  we are all white and they are all brown.  Clear divisions.  Us and them.  I tried to listen to the woman guiding the tour, telling us about the amazing, necessary work they do at Carmichael, but I couldn’t stop thinking about how privileged I am.

Usually privilege is obscure and very easy to ignore.  I can get through most days believing I have earned the things I have and that my life is the way it is because of my own hard work and the hard work of my parents.  That day at Carmichael, several of my positions of privilege (being white, middle class, able-bodied, not having a mental illness), were blatantly apparent.  It was obvious that my life is the way it is because of this privilege, and that made me feel uncomfortable and awkward and guilty.

I know that I don’t have to feel guilty about my privilege because I can’t help it, but I couldn’t stop feeling guilty throughout the tour.  I kept thinking about the combined value of just the clothing that my classmates and I were wearing and how much money that could bring to an organization like this.

Back to the tour.  I was really surprised at the number of containers of food they give out every day at Carmichael – up to 250 of the tall yogurt containers (which they are always in need of)!  The need for this food security program has gone up in the last five years, she told us.  I was also impressed with the used clothing and small household item depot, where anyone in need can come take them, free of charge.  This is something I could easily help out with by donating old clothes and winter attire that I don’t use anymore.  That’s one small way I could help make a difference, but I still feel guilty.

I am aware of a few other supports in Regina to assist families, including the Food Bank and Regina Women’s Transition House.  Other than those, I’m pretty ignorant about the supports available and I definitely need to do some research to change that.

This experience made me think about how I will support students who live in poverty situations in my future classroom.  First of all, I need to become more educated on the supports available for families in Regina so that I am able to refer families to these supports or make suggestions that might help them.  In my classroom, I want to have breakfast and snacks available for all my students, so as not to single anyone out but to make sure they have all eaten.  I also want to try to do classroom fundraisers for field trips or other experiences so that students aren’t left out if they cannot afford the trip.  I want to teach for equity – not equality – which means doing my best to level the playing field so everyone can learn to their full potential.

Also, I will need to examine the stereotypes I bring and be careful not to deficit theorize about students’ families.  For example, if parents don’t come to a parent-teacher interview, I hope to be invested in the relationship enough to know that it’s not that they don’t care about their child’s schooling, but that they might have other priorities that are taking over.  I want to be open, caring, and easy to talk to, not judgmental.  I also want to have high expectations for all my students and make sure I label them as at-promise rather than at-risk, because I know the expectations (high or low) I place on students are likely to be fulfilled.

Finally, I think it’s really important to talk about poverty in the classroom.  If I make it a taboo topic, I am placing shame on my students who live out that reality.  Without singling anyone out, we can talk and learn about it together.  I want to help my students break down stereotypes they might have about people who live in poverty and find ways our class can make a difference.  One resource I have been exposed to for doing this is the Ladybug Foundation.

So I have some ideas for what I need to do in my future classroom to support students who live in poverty.  But after my experience at Carmichael Outreach, I’m wondering:  What do I do with my feelings of guilt and awkwardness?  How do I close the gap between self and other that I felt?  How can I use my privilege to make a difference?

Any suggestions would be much appreciated!

2 thoughts on “Carmichael Outreach Reflection

  1. Anonymous

    On the topic of privilege:

    It’s true that ethnic and social class have created divisions throughout the world, be it tribal feuding in Africa, the oppression of Chinese minorities by the Han Chinese ethnic group, or the historical oppression of aboriginal peoples in Canada. My opinion on the burgeoning buzzword of “privilege” is that is does absolutely nothing to try to mend those gaps: rather, it chooses to put repeated emphasis on our divisions, which serves only to spread those divisions even further apart. I am on the outside looking in, as I am not a student of education, but as a 3rd party bystander I cannot help but feel that the only discussion that is happening in topics such as this are the browbeating of white Canadians into guilt and humiliation, and burgeoning resentment of aboriginal peoples against their oppressors:

    Because that is how we are painted in this discussion: “Us and them”, “oppressors and oppressed”. How can anyone not infer that talk like this without any other balance will lead to yet more aggression, violence, and resentment? The discussion of the people of Canada as people, standing together, takes a back seat to the encouragement of anger and separation. Accusations of “accepting white privilege” takes precedence over “all people are equal”.

    Our history is dirty. That is a fact. And we do have to talk about it to make sure it doesn’t happen again and to make sure we learn from our mistakes. My only qualm is that it is taking far too great of a priority over the progression of society past these mistakes, rather than dwelling on them.

  2. raquelbellefleur Post author

    Thank you for your comment! There’s a lot to think about here.

    I think you’re saying that we shouldn’t focus so much on privilege because it emphasizes divisions rather than on equality or on Canadians standing together. However, I think the reason we hear so much about privilege and “checking our privilege” is because all people are not equal in society. Privilege means that power is unequally distributed, and not just in dirty history, but in our society today.

    I agree with you that we need to work on progressing in a united way as a society rather than dwelling on mistakes in history, but I think that to progress we need to talk about privilege. Recognizing white privilege means making an effort to listen to traditionally marginalized voices (i.e. Aboriginal perspectives), educating yourself by seeking out resources/experiences (i.e. participating in a sweat lodge ceremony), and trying to use your privilege for good (i.e. speaking out when you hear a racist slur) – all of which, I think, would help our society progress.

    So I guess what I’m saying is that recognizing privilege doesn’t mean emphasizing “us and them” and making white Canadians feel guilty. It actually means doing things to try to close the gap between “us and them” so we can progress in a united way.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s